Coaching Baseball: Dealing With Difficult Coaches

Many of us have run across the “difficult” youth baseball coach.

Ever wanted a real expert’s advice on how to deal with the problem?

Here’s a great article from Sports Parents.Com about how to deal with
“The Difficult Coach.”

Dealing With Difficult Coaches

Volunteer coaches mean well, but they don’t always do well. Here’s how to handle the worst.

Most youth league coaches are kindhearted volunteers. These women and men try hard to make sports enjoyable and rewarding for kids.

But some coaches can be dictatorial, disorganized, or sneaky. Concerned parents should watch out for difficult coaches as carefully as they watch for problem teachers.

Here’s a look at some of the most worrisome coaching types and how to deal with them.

The Drill Sargeant

You’ve seen this one: He runs practices and games in a strict, no-nonsense fashion. He benches or chastises players for making a mistake. His philosophy seems to be “The only way to have fun in sports is to win — all the time.”

Children take their sports seriously enough without this kind of pressure. Under the Drill Sergeant, your child is apt to play all season motivated by fear of losing or making a mistake. Good coaches say that the kids who are having fun on the field are the ones who win, not the other way around.

What to do:
If you know before the season starts that your child has a Drill Sergeant, try to move the child to another team right away. Don’t wait; once team rosters are set, it’s hard to make changes. Tell the league’s commissioner that you think it’s best for your child and the coach.

Coaches who act like drill sergeants can terrify young players:

If the coach is in charge of an elite team or you can’t get a transfer, try talking with the coach in a non-confrontational way. If that doesn’t help, talk to your child. Say that coaches are different, this coach especially so, and that he shouldn’t let the coach’s harsh methods bother him. If you can’t get the coach to act like a mature adult, maybe you can get your child to be the grown-up.

The Screaming Apologist

This coach takes winning too seriously, but he knows better. Early on, he tells the team: “If I raise my voice during the game, please understand that I’m just yelling because of the excitement and because I want you to play well.”

This disclaimer given, the Screaming Apologist feels he has carte blanche to berate umpires and to verbally abuse players during the game. Once the contest is over, the coach is all smiles and sweetness again. Meanwhile, your kid starts to flinch at the thought of playing for this maniac.

What to do:
Give the coach a chance. Explain, in a quiet, private discussion, that you’re concerned about his outbursts. Many coaches will change their ways when they realize someone is watching. If the coach says he can’t control himself, try moving your child to another team.

The Big League Know-It-All

As you might suspect, this is the coach who wants all the players to do everything precisely the way he says to. That can be a problem, especially if your child wants to try a different approach-say, a batting stance that feels more natural to him.

Most big league ballplayers will tell you that there are many different ways to hit a baseball. Some batters choke up. Some take long, looping swings. As long as it works, it’s okay. There will be plenty of time in junior high and high school to hone techniques to perfection. At younger ages, it’s much more important that kids just enjoy playing the game.

What to do:
If you see the storm clouds gathering on your kid’s face when a coach insists, “Hold the bat this way!” speak up. Remind the coach that when a child is nine or 10, his individual style of holding a bat or dribbling a soccer ball really doesn’t make much difference.

My son wanted to try switch- hitting when he was eight. One of his coaches told him no, he should swing right-handed only. I saw the disappointment in my son’s face, so I asked the coach in a calm, direct manner, “What better time to learn how to switch-hit? Why discourage him now?” The coach got my point.

The Conniver

Every community has one. This is the coach who looks for every loophole in the league rule book to make certain his team is the best. There’s often some politicking or eligibility-rule bending to stack his team.

During games, the Conniver might order his weaker hitters to try to get walks, instead of swinging away, or encourage his kids to heckle their rivals. This does happen.

What to do:
Again, speak up. Find out how teams and players are selected before the league coaches and commissioner get together to go over rosters, and make your suspicions known. If the season has already started, talk with other parents who share your concerns and, as a group, send a letter to the commissioner, specifying the incidents.

The Casual Coach

Believe it or not, the Casual Coach may do more to take the fun out of your child’s athletic experience than any other type of volunteer coach.

Letting the kids have fun is great, but being too casual is a problem.
At the start of the season, he tells kids and parents that “all that matters to me is that everybody has fun.” While that may sound promising-and good coaches live up to that promise-the Casual Coach uses it as an excuse. He doesn’t take time to organize practices (“Let’s just scrimmage again, okay?”) and routinely arrives late or misses practices and games. This coach doesn’t really teach skills. He doesn’t keep track of the players to make sure they all get to play different positions and get similar playing time.

Before long, you’ll find your child’s enthusiasm for the games and practices drooping. Why? The coach’s lax attitude has given youngsters on the team the message that they don’t need to care either.

What to do:

For A Younger Team:
Offer to help. Tactfully tell the coach some of the things you think should be happening and why, and add that you would be glad to assist him in any way you can. Remember, your object is for your child to learn skills and have a chance to enjoy using them.

For An Older/Travel Team:
Ask the coach what he sees in your child? What does he believe is their strong/weak skills and what he can do to be better, contribute to the team? Let him know if you are getting special instruction and it may be in conflict with what he is teaching. Open dialog is the only way that these types of issues can be solved. Most coaches are open to this type of dialog .But as parents we must understand that only 9 players play at once but it takes 12-18 to make a TEAM.

As your child continues up the ladder they will find that they are players on the TEAM. Everyone is good. Everyone will contribute and must be ready when they are called.

  • Parents can help coaches by reinforcing these values.
  • As a coach the best player is a coachable player.
  • Players who understand how to be part of a team will go far.

Virginia Scouting Director:
Mike Powers
Scout Number s2708


If you have a question about baseball coaching answered in the Digital Dugout, please use the form on the Contact Us, page, Coach Kuebler or one of our faculty coaches will respond and we’ll email you when the post gets published.

In the meantime you may want to check out our Baseball Coaching & Drill Videos here.

About CoachK

Owner and head instructor at Colonial Baseball Instruction. CBI serves Southern VA with baseball camps and private lessons. CBI also developed My Coach: Baseball App and sells a variety of baseball training aids.